Two Out of Three Highly Paid Fund Managers Just Lost to an Index Fund With No Manager at All. So Why Are You Still Paying Them?

Once a year, an envelope arrives. Inside is your fund statement, full of charts, smiling photos and words like "disciplined" and "conviction." Somewhere in the small print is the fee you paid a team of professionals to beat the market.
Here is what that envelope never tells you.
In the first half of 2026, 67% of actively managed U.S. large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500. So roughly two out of three professional stock pickers lost to an index fund that has no manager, no research team and no corner office. Over 20 years, 92.6% of them lost.
The short answer What percentage of fund managers beat the S&P 500? In the first half of 2026, only about 33% of active U.S. large-cap funds matched or beat the S&P 500. Over 10 years it was about 17%. Over 20 years it was about 7%, roughly 7 in every 100. Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA U.S. Scorecard Mid-Year 2026 (data to June 30, 2026). |
If you have ever lost money in the market and wondered whether paying an expert was the "safe" choice, this article is for you. You will see the latest numbers, what the gap means in real dollars, why so many smart people lose, and a simple check you can run on your own fund tonight.
The scorecard the fund industry doesn't advertise
Every six months, S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes a report called the SPIVA Scorecard. SPIVA stands for "S&P Indices Versus Active." It has been running for more than 25 years.
It does one simple thing. It takes every actively managed fund in a category and asks: did this fund beat the index it was trying to beat, after fees?
Three things make SPIVA hard to argue with.
No. 1: It counts the dead funds. Fund companies quietly close or merge their worst performers. Their marketing then shows only the survivors. SPIVA keeps the losers in the count, so the picture isn't flattered.
No. 2: It compares like with like. Large-company funds are measured against the S&P 500. Small-company funds are measured against a small-company index. Nobody gets an easy target.
No. 3: It uses returns after fees. That is the money you actually keep, not the number on a brochure.
You don't need to be an expert to read it. You only need to know one number: the percentage of funds that underperformed. Subtract it from 100 and you have the percentage that matched or beat the market.
The latest numbers: how many fund managers beat the S&P 500
Here is the most watched comparison in the whole report: active U.S. large-cap funds against the S&P 500.
Time period (to June 30, 2026) | Funds that lost to the S&P 500 | Funds that matched or beat it |
|---|---|---|
First half of 2026 | 67.2% | 32.8% |
1 year | 78.7% | 21.3% |
3 years | 76.6% | 23.4% |
5 years | 89.3% | 10.7% |
10 years | 83.3% | 16.7% |
15 years | 90.5% | 9.5% |
20 years | 92.6% | 7.4% |
Source: SPIVA U.S. Scorecard Mid-Year 2026, Report 1a.

Read the table from top to bottom and you will notice a pattern. The longer the time period, the fewer managers win. In any single year, a fair number get lucky. Over a working lifetime of investing, almost none do.
And 2025 was worse than 2026 so far. In full-year 2025, 79% of active large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500. S&P Dow Jones Indices called it the fourth-worst year for these managers in the 25-year history of the scorecard.
"But surely 2026 was a stock picker's market?"
That is the part that should make you sit up.
For three years, critics said managers lost because a handful of giant tech companies carried the index, and nobody could keep up. In the first half of 2026, that excuse disappeared. Smaller companies finally led. The S&P MidCap 400 rose 17% and the S&P SmallCap 600 rose 24%, while the S&P 500 rose 10%.
That gave large-cap managers an easy way to win: tilt toward smaller stocks. The report's own authors said these favourable conditions were still not enough for most managers to take advantage of. Two out of three still lost.
The managers who specialise in smaller companies didn't do better either. 74% of mid-cap funds and 69% of small-cap funds trailed their own benchmarks in the same six months.
What the gap costs you in real money
Percentages feel abstract. Dollars don't.
SPIVA also reports the actual average returns. Over the 20 years to June 2026, the S&P 500 returned 11.39% a year. The average active large-cap fund returned 9.47% a year. Weighted by the money invested in each fund, the figure was 10.33% a year.
Two percentage points a year sounds small. Now let it compound on $100,000 for 20 years.
$100,000 invested for 20 years | Yearly return | Ending value |
|---|---|---|
S&P 500 | 11.39% | $864,817 |
Average dollar in active funds (asset-weighted) | 10.33% | $714,286 |
Average active fund (equal-weighted) | 9.47% | $610,805 |

That is a gap of $150,000 to $254,000 for every $100,000 you invested. It doesn't come from a crash, a bad stock or a scam. It is simply what "slightly below the market" adds up to over two decades.
One honest note: you can't buy the index itself. A low-cost index fund charges a small fee, often 0.03% to 0.10% a year, so it trails the index by about that much. That is a rounding error next to a two-point gap.
If you want to see this effect on your own savings, my post on the "tiny" 1% fee that can quietly steal a quarter of your retirement walks through it step by step.
The fund graveyard nobody talks about
Here is a number that doesn't appear in any fund advert.
SPIVA tracks what happened to every U.S. stock fund that existed at the start of each period. After 20 years, only 37.85% were still alive. The rest, about 62%, had been merged into other funds or shut down.

Why does this matter to you?
Because funds rarely close when they are winning. They close after years of poor results, when investors have left. The fund company then rolls the remaining money into another fund and the bad record quietly disappears.
So when someone shows you a list of "top-performing funds over 10 years," remember you are looking at the survivors. The losers have already been removed from the race. SPIVA counts them. Brochures don't.
"Then I'll just pick the winners." Here's the problem
This is the natural next thought. If 7% of managers win over 20 years, why not just find those 7%?
S&P Dow Jones Indices answers this in a separate report, the U.S. Persistence Scorecard. It asks a simple question: do last year's star funds stay stars?
The answer, for the period to December 2025, is mostly no.
Of the 173 large-cap funds in the top quarter of performers in 2023, 29% stayed in the top quarter through 2025.
Of the large-cap funds in the top quarter in 2021, none stayed in the top quarter every year through 2025. Zero.
Of the large-cap funds in the top half in 2021, only 4.5% stayed in the top half every year through 2025. Pure coin-flip luck would have given you 6.25%.

In other words, picking a fund because it topped last year's chart is about as reliable as picking one by tossing a coin. Sometimes worse.
The man who beat the market 15 years in a row
If anyone proved that skill could last, it was Bill Miller.
His Legg Mason Value Trust beat the S&P 500 every calendar year from 1991 to 2005. Fifteen years straight. Fortune magazine called him the greatest money manager of all time, and investors poured billions into his fund.
Then the streak ended. In 2006, the fund gained about 5.9% while the S&P 500 rose about 15.8%, according to Bloomberg. In a letter to investors in January 2007, Miller himself put the streak's end down partly to mistakes and partly to bad luck.
What followed was harder. From January 2006 to October 2011, Value Trust lost 36% while the S&P 500 gained 13%, as reported by InvestmentNews. Anyone who bought in after reading about the famous streak caught the decline instead.
This isn't a story about a bad manager. Miller was, by any measure, one of the most talented investors of his generation. It is a story about how even the best record can turn, and how the people who buy in after reading the headlines often get the worst of it.
Why smart, highly paid professionals keep losing
Fund managers are not fools. Most are intelligent, hard-working and well trained. So why do so many trail a fund that just buys everything?
Reason No. 1: The arithmetic is against them
In 1991, Nobel Prize-winning economist William Sharpe explained this in a short paper called "The Arithmetic of Active Management."
His logic is simple. All the money in the market, added together, is the market. So before costs, the average actively managed dollar must earn the market's return. Some managers beat it, others trail it, and they average out to the market.
Then you subtract costs. Active managers charge more and trade more. So after costs, the average active dollar must trail the market. This isn't opinion. It is arithmetic.
Reason No. 2: Fees come out every single year
A manager has to beat the market by more than their fee just to break even with an index fund. Win one year, lose the next, and the fee is still taken both times.
Reason No. 3: A few huge winners make most of the money
Professor Hendrik Bessembinder of Arizona State University studied every U.S. stock from 1926 to 2016. He found that the best-performing 4% of listed companies explain the entire net gain of the U.S. stock market over that period. The other 96%, taken together, did no better than short-term Treasury bills. His study was published in the Journal of Financial Economics in 2018.
Think about what that means. An index fund owns all of those rare superstars automatically. A manager who holds 50 or 80 stocks has to find them in advance. Miss a few and the whole fund falls behind. Bessembinder himself said his results help explain why poorly diversified active strategies most often underperform.
Reason No. 4: Cash and trading costs
Active funds keep some cash on hand to pay investors who leave. They also buy and sell more often, which adds trading costs that don't show up in the headline fee. Each is small. Together, year after year, they add up.
Reason No. 5: Career risk
Warren Buffett has pointed out that advisers would be committing career suicide if they told wealthy clients, year after year, simply to keep adding to an S&P 500 index fund. Clients expect activity for their fees. So the industry keeps selling activity, even when stillness would serve the client better.
Warren Buffett put $1 million on this
In late 2007, Warren Buffett made a 10-year, $1 million bet for charity. He said a simple S&P 500 index fund would beat a set of hedge funds chosen by professionals, after all fees.
Ted Seides of Protégé Partners took the bet. He picked five "funds of funds," which together held interests in more than 200 hedge funds. These were some of the highest-paid managers in the world.
The final results, published in Buffett's 2017 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, were not close.
2008 to 2017 | Total gain |
|---|---|
Fund of funds A | 21.7% |
Fund of funds B | 42.3% |
Fund of funds C | 87.7% |
Fund of funds D | 2.8% |
Fund of funds E | 27.0% |
Vanguard S&P 500 index fund | 125.8% |

The index fund averaged 8.5% a year. The five professional portfolios averaged roughly 2.9% a year. Buffett noted that fixed fees of around 2.5% of assets were paid every year, win or lose. His summary: "Performance comes, performance goes. Fees never falter."
The winnings, about $2.2 million in the end, went to Girls Inc. of Omaha. I tell the whole story in How a Boring Index Fund Beat Five Teams of Wall Street's Highest-Paid Money Managers, and what Buffett told his own family to do with their money in Warren Buffett's one-sentence instruction to his wife.
It isn't just an American problem
Many readers of this site live outside the United States. You might think, "That's U.S. funds. Our managers know our market better."
S&P Dow Jones Indices runs the same scorecard around the world. The pattern repeats.
Canada: In the first half of 2026, 79% of Canadian funds investing in U.S. stocks trailed the S&P 500. In 2025, 89.1% did.
United Kingdom: In 2025, 89% of U.K. large- and mid-cap equity funds trailed their benchmark. In the first half of 2026, 90% did.
Japan: Here is an honest exception. In the first half of 2026, more than 7 in 10 Japanese large-cap funds beat their benchmark. But over the 10 and 15 years to December 2025, more than 80% of them trailed it.
Pension and institutional money: Even managers running money for big institutions struggle. In 2025, 67% of U.S. large-cap institutional accounts trailed the S&P 500, and that was before their fees.
A good year or two can happen anywhere. Over long periods, the same result keeps showing up in country after country.
If you live outside America and want to own the S&P 500 directly, start with how anyone, in any country, can own America's 500 biggest companies. If you're in Canada, see the best S&P 500 ETF for your TFSA.
The fee you can see, and the ones you can't
Fees have come down a lot. According to the Investment Company Institute, the average expense ratio for U.S. equity mutual funds fell from 1.04% in 1996 to 0.40% in 2025. That's good news.
But the averages hide a big gap between active and passive funds. Morningstar's 2026 U.S. Fund Fee Study found that in 2025, investors paid an asset-weighted average of 0.57% a year for actively managed funds and 0.09% for broad index funds. Many large index funds and ETFs now charge less than 0.05%.
Outside the U.S., and when you buy through a bank or an agent, fees are often higher still. Many investors also pay a separate adviser or "wrap" fee of around 1% a year on top of the fund's own fee.
Here is what those layers do over 20 years. Assume $100,000 earns 8% a year before costs (a round number for illustration, not a forecast).
Annual cost | Value after 20 years |
|---|---|
Low-cost index fund (0.05%) | $461,799 |
Average active fund (0.57%) | $419,287 |
Active fund plus a 1% adviser fee (1.57%) | $347,761 |

That's more than $114,000 lost to costs alone, and this assumes the active fund matches the market before fees. As the SPIVA numbers show, most don't.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission makes the same point on Investor.gov. In its example, $100,000 growing at 4% a year for 20 years ends at about $208,000 with a 0.25% fee, but only about $179,000 with a 1% fee.
Want to see your own number? Try my free Hidden Fee Calculator. It takes about two minutes.
Fees you might not see on your statement
Sales charges (also called loads or initial charges), taken when you buy. Some funds sold through agents and banks take several percent of your money upfront.
Ongoing distribution or "trail" fees paid to the person who sold you the fund.
Trading costs inside the fund, which reduce returns but aren't part of the expense ratio.
Adviser, platform or wrap fees, charged on top of everything else.
If you bought your fund through a bank, read what your "relationship manager" never told you before your next review meeting.
So why are you still paying them?
If the numbers are this clear, why do millions of sensible people keep paying for active management? Here are the six reasons I hear most, and what the evidence says about each.
"My fund has done well."
Maybe it has. But compared with what? A fund that rose 60% over five years sounds great until you learn its benchmark rose 90%. Always compare your fund with its own index over the same period. The factsheet usually shows both.
"I was told it's safer to have a professional."
Active funds fall in crashes too. Look at the Buffett bet table: in 2008, the five professional portfolios fell between about 16% and 30%. They lost less than the index that year, then badly trailed it for the next nine. A professional can't stop the market from falling. They can only charge you while it does.
"I like having a person to call."
That is a fair thing to value. But you can have a person and low-cost index funds. Many fee-only advisers build index portfolios. Just know exactly what you're paying for the advice, and make sure it isn't also hidden inside an expensive fund.
"I'm afraid of doing it wrong on my own."
An S&P 500 index fund is one of the simplest investments there is. It doesn't need you to pick stocks, time the market or read the news. My guide on set-and-forget investing shows how little effort it really takes.
"I've already paid so much. I can't stop now."
That's the sunk-cost trap. Fees you've already paid are gone either way. The only question that matters is which choice gives you the most money from today forward.
"Switching will cost me."
Sometimes it will, through taxes or exit charges. That is a real reason to plan the switch carefully. It isn't a reason to keep paying high fees for another 20 years. We'll cover how to switch without a second mistake below.
The question to ask your adviser "Over the last 10 years, after all fees, has my fund beaten a low-cost index fund that tracks the same market? Please show me both numbers side by side." A good adviser will answer in one meeting. If you get a speech instead of two numbers, that's your answer. |
In fairness: when an active fund can still make sense
I want to be fair here, because this is your money and you deserve the full picture.
Some managers do beat the market. About 7 in 100 large-cap funds did over 20 years. The problem isn't that winners don't exist. It's that nobody has found a reliable way to identify them in advance.
Some markets are less one-sided. In the first half of 2026, only 38% of U.S.-based emerging markets funds trailed their benchmark, and bond funds did better than stock funds on average. The results vary by year and by category, so check the scorecard for the market you're actually investing in.
Low-cost active funds start with a smaller handicap. A fund charging 0.3% has a much easier job than one charging 1.5%. If you prefer active management, cost is the first filter to use.
Your situation matters. Taxes, retirement accounts, employer plans and how much you have invested can all change the right answer. That's why the next section is a decision map, not a command.
Keep, cut or switch? A simple decision map
Use this map with your fund's factsheet in front of you.

In words:
Step 1: Has your fund beaten its own benchmark index, after all fees, over the last 10 years (or since you bought it, if longer)?
Step 2: If no, your next question is about exit costs. Will selling trigger a tax bill or a surrender or exit charge?
Step 3: If exit costs are low, consider moving to a low-cost index fund that tracks the same market. If they are high, stop adding new money to the old fund, send new savings to an index fund, and plan the move over time.
Step 4: If yes, your fund has beaten its benchmark, check two more things. Is the same manager still running it? Are the total fees reasonable, ideally under about 0.75% a year including any adviser fee?
Step 5: If both answers are yes, keeping it can be reasonable. Review it once a year against the index. If either answer is no, treat it like a fund that didn't beat its benchmark.
Your 15-minute fund check for tonight
You don't need to make any decision tonight. You only need to find out where you stand.
Your 15-minute checklist No. 1: Find the latest factsheet for each fund you own (search the fund's name plus "factsheet"). No. 2: Write down its total annual cost (expense ratio, TER or "ongoing charges figure"). No. 3: Write down its 10-year return and its benchmark's 10-year return. Both are usually on the factsheet. No. 4: Add any adviser, platform or wrap fee you pay on top. No. 5: Put the numbers into the free Hidden Fee Calculator to see the 20-year cost. No. 6: Check for exit costs: sales charges, surrender periods and capital gains tax. No. 7: Sleep on it. Decide with a clear head, not in a panic. |
Most people who do this check for the first time are surprised by at least one number. That surprise is useful. It's the moment you stop being a customer and start being an investor.
How to switch without making a second mistake
People who have been burned once often make a second mistake when they fix the first. Here is how to avoid that.
Don't sell everything in a panic. Moving from an active fund to an index fund is a long-term decision, not a market-timing move. If the market is falling, that's no reason to rush. If it's at a record high, that's no reason to wait either. My post on whether to invest at an all-time high shows why.
Check the tax first. In a taxable account, selling a fund at a gain may create a tax bill. In tax-sheltered accounts such as a U.S. IRA or 401(k), a Canadian TFSA or RRSP, or a U.K. ISA, switching inside the account usually doesn't. Rules differ by country, so check with your tax office or a qualified adviser.
Check exit charges. Some funds and insurance-linked products charge a fee if you leave within a set period. Sometimes waiting a few months for a charge to expire is the cheaper path.
Redirect new money first. The simplest step is often to stop adding to the expensive fund and send all new savings to a low-cost index fund. You can move the old money later, in stages.
Choose a simple index fund that suits where you live. For many non-U.S. investors, an Ireland-domiciled S&P 500 ETF can reduce dividend tax and U.S. estate tax risk. Compare the options in VOO, CSPX or VT.
Don't switch from one star manager to another. The persistence data above shows why. Chasing last year's winner is how many investors lose money in the first place, as I explain in the 7 Wall Street traps that quietly drain ordinary investors.
If you hold a unit trust or a fund that is currently down, read 5 questions to ask before you sell, switch or hold and should you sell your losing stocks and move to index funds? first.
And if you're worried that an S&P 500 fund is too dependent on a few tech giants, I cover that honestly in Is your "safe" S&P 500 fund secretly a bet on 7 tech companies?
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of fund managers beat the S&P 500?
According to S&P Dow Jones Indices' SPIVA U.S. Mid-Year 2026 Scorecard, about 33% of active U.S. large-cap funds matched or beat the S&P 500 in the first half of 2026. Over 10 years about 17% did, and over 20 years only about 7%. The longer the period, the fewer managers win.
How many fund managers beat the S&P 500 over 20 years?
About 7.4% of active U.S. large-cap funds matched or beat the S&P 500 over the 20 years to June 30, 2026. The other 92.6% trailed it. Many of the losing funds were also closed or merged along the way, which SPIVA keeps in its count.
What is the SPIVA Scorecard?
SPIVA stands for S&P Indices Versus Active. It is a report published twice a year by S&P Dow Jones Indices comparing actively managed funds with their benchmark indexes, after fees. It includes funds that closed, so the results aren't flattered by removing the losers.
Why do most active fund managers underperform the S&P 500?
Mainly because of costs and arithmetic. Before costs, the average active dollar earns the market return. After higher fees and trading costs, it must trail. Also, a small number of stocks drive most market gains, and concentrated portfolios often miss them.
Is an index fund better than an actively managed fund?
Over long periods, the evidence says a low-cost index fund beats most actively managed funds in the same market. That doesn't mean every active fund is bad. It means the odds of picking a long-term winner in advance are low, and costs are certain.
Did any fund managers beat the S&P 500 in 2026?
Yes. About one in three active U.S. large-cap funds matched or beat the S&P 500 in the first half of 2026. The challenge is that the winners change from year to year, so last year's top funds are rarely next year's.
Should I sell my actively managed fund?
Not in a hurry. First compare its 10-year return with its benchmark after all fees, then check exit costs and taxes. Many people start by sending new money to a low-cost index fund and moving older money gradually. This is general education, not personal advice.
The bottom line
You were never foolish for trusting a professional. You were told that experts do better than ordinary people, and that sounded like common sense.
The scorecard says otherwise. Two out of three managers trailed the market in the first half of 2026. Over 20 years, more than nine out of ten did. And the few who won rarely stayed on top.
The good news is that the fix isn't complicated. You don't need to outsmart anyone. You need to own the whole market cheaply, add to it steadily and give it time. The odds then move in your favour instead of the fund company's.
If you've lost money in the market before, it may help to understand exactly why. My free 38-page report, "Why You Lost Money in the Stock Market (And Why It Wasn't Your Fault)," explains the traps that cost ordinary investors the most, why so much of it wasn't your fault, and the simpler path that puts the odds back on your side. It's free, and it takes one evening to read.
About the author
Stephen Loke has been a student of the market for more than 15 years. He is also an agritourism entrepreneur whose farm has been featured in Bloomberg News and Asahi Shimbun.
This article is general education, not personal financial advice. I'm not a licensed financial adviser. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Please consider your own situation, and speak to a qualified, licensed professional before making investment decisions.
Sources
S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA U.S. Scorecard Mid-Year 2026 (data to June 30, 2026): https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/documents/spiva/spiva-us-mid-year-2026.pdf
S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA U.S. Year-End 2025: https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-us-year-end-2025/
S&P Dow Jones Indices, U.S. Persistence Scorecard Year-End 2025: https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/documents/spiva/persistence-scorecard-year-end-2025.pdf
S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Institutional Scorecard Year-End 2025: https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/documents/spiva/spiva-institutional-scorecard-year-end-2025.pdf
S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Canada Year-End 2025 and Mid-Year 2026: https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-canada
S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Europe Year-End 2025 and Mid-Year 2026: https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-europe-year-end-2025/
S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Japan Year-End 2025 and Mid-Year 2026: https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-japan-year-end-2025/
Berkshire Hathaway, 2016 Letter to Shareholders ("The Bet" section): https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2016ltr.pdf
Berkshire Hathaway, 2017 Letter to Shareholders: https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2017ltr.pdf
Hendrik Bessembinder, "Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills?", Journal of Financial Economics, 2018: https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:eee:jfinec:v:129:y:2018:i:3:p:440-457
William F. Sharpe, "The Arithmetic of Active Management," Financial Analysts Journal, 1991: https://web.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/active/active.htm
Investment Company Institute, Trends in the Expenses and Fees of Funds, 2025: https://www.ici.org/news-release/mutual-fund-and-etf-fees-remained-near-historic-lows-in-2025
Morningstar, U.S. Fund Fee Study 2026: https://www.morningstar.com/funds/how-active-etfs-are-reshaping-fund-fees
U.S. SEC, Investor.gov, Understanding Fees: https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/getting-started/understanding-fees
CNNMoney, "Bill Miller's streak strikes out," December 2006: https://money.cnn.com/2006/12/29/pf/funds/miller/index.htm
Financial Planning (citing Bloomberg), "Miller's 15-Year Streak Ends With a Thud": https://www.financial-planning.com/news/millers-15-year-streak-ends-with-a-thud
Reuters via IBTimes, "Miller's Fall Shows Luck at Play in Investing": https://www.ibtimes.com/millers-fall-shows-luck-play-investing-651755
MoneyWeek, "Guru watch: Fund star Bill Miller falls to earth": https://moneyweek.com/30232/guru-watch-fund-manager-bill-miller-resigns-56509
InvestmentNews, "Do call it a comeback: Bill Miller's old fund starts a new streak": https://www.investmentnews.com/mutual-funds/do-call-it-a-comeback-bill-millers-old-fund-starts-a-new-streak/51702




Comments