The Best S&P 500 ETF for Your TFSA, and the Withholding Tax Mistake Many Canadians Make

You did the responsible thing. You opened a Tax-Free Savings Account, bought an S&P 500 fund, and told yourself every dollar of growth would be yours, tax-free, forever.
Then you look closely at a dividend and notice a slice is missing. Nobody sent you a bill. The money simply never arrived.
The short answer For most Canadians, the best S&P 500 ETF for a TFSA is a low-cost, Canadian-listed, unhedged fund: VFV (0.08% MER), ZSP (0.09%) or XUS (0.09%). Inside a TFSA, every one of them loses 15% of its US dividends to withholding tax. So does the US-listed VOO. At today's dividend yield, that costs about 0.17% a year. Don't pay more than that to avoid it. |
That missing slice is the 15% US withholding tax. It is the fine print hiding inside the word "tax-free," and it catches a lot of careful Canadians off guard.
Here's the problem. Some people find out and panic. They sell, switch to a US-listed fund, or pay extra for a special "no withholding" structure. Most of those moves cost more than the tax they were running from.
In this guide, you'll see exactly how the 15% works, what it really costs in dollars, how the seven S&P 500 ETFs Canadians buy compare, and the three mistakes that turn a small leak into a big one.
Table of contents
The Fine Print Inside the Word "Tax-Free"
The United States taxes dividends that American companies pay to foreign investors. The default rate is 30%.
Canada and the US have a tax treaty that cuts that rate to 15% for Canadian residents. Your brokerage applies the lower rate once you have signed a form called the W-8BEN.
The treaty goes further for retirement accounts. US dividends paid into an RRSP or RRIF are exempt, but only when you hold the US stock or US-listed ETF directly.
Your TFSA gets no such break. The US does not recognize the TFSA as a retirement account, so the 15% is taken off every US dividend before it lands.
In a regular taxable account, you could claim that 15% back as a foreign tax credit when you file your Canadian return. Inside a TFSA, you pay no Canadian tax on the dividend, so there is nothing to claim the credit against. The money is simply gone.
Two pieces of good news keep this in proportion:
The tax applies to dividends only. Your capital gains inside the TFSA stay completely tax-free.
The S&P 500 pays a small dividend today, so 15% of it is a small number.
The same rule applies to the First Home Savings Account (FHSA) and the RESP. They are not treated as retirement accounts under the treaty either.

The Surprise: Switching to VOO Doesn't Fix It
Here is where many Canadians get tripped up.
They learn that VFV pays a 15% tax inside the fund. So they think, "I'll skip the Canadian middleman and buy VOO, the American original, directly."
Inside a TFSA, that changes nothing. VOO's dividends reach your TFSA with 15% already withheld. VFV's dividends reach the Canadian fund with 15% already withheld. It is the same 15%, taken once, either way.
Portfolio manager Justin Bender and planner Dan Bortolotti of PWL Capital studied this in detail in their white paper on foreign withholding taxes. Their conclusion for TFSAs and RESPs was plain: use Canadian-listed ETFs for foreign stocks, because US-listed ETFs give you no tax advantage in those accounts.
The only place a US-listed fund wins on withholding tax is your RRSP or RRIF, where the treaty exemption applies. Hold a Canadian-listed fund like VFV in your RRSP and the 15% is still lost inside the fund, because the exemption only covers US securities you own directly.
Account | US-listed ETF (VOO, IVV, SPY) | Canadian-listed ETF (VFV, ZSP, XUS) | Can you get the 15% back? |
TFSA | 15% lost | 15% lost | No |
FHSA or RESP | 15% lost | 15% lost | No |
RRSP or RRIF | 0% (treaty exemption) | 15% lost inside the fund | Not needed for US-listed |
Non-registered (taxable) | 15% withheld | 15% withheld | Usually yes, as a foreign tax credit |
So the question for your TFSA is not "how do I avoid the 15%?" It is "which fund gives me the S&P 500 at the lowest total cost, given that the 15% applies anyway?"
How Much Does the 15% Really Cost You?
Let's put real numbers on it.
S&P Dow Jones Indices reported that the S&P 500's trailing 12-month dividend yield was just 1.12% at the end of April 2026. That was the lowest in its records going back to 2002, and well below the 1.83% average over that time.
Take 15% of a 1.1% yield and you get about 0.165% a year. That is roughly:
$1.65 a year for every $1,000 in your TFSA
$16.50 a year for every $10,000
About $180 a year if you have used the full $109,000 of TFSA room available to someone eligible since 2009
Over long periods, small drags compound. Put $100,000 into the S&P 500 and assume it grows 7% a year for 20 years. With no withholding drag, you end with about $387,000. With a 0.165% yearly drag, you end with about $375,200. The difference is roughly $11,800.
That is real money. It is also far less than most people imagine when they first hear "15% tax." You are not losing 15% of your returns. You are losing 15% of a dividend that is only about 1% of your balance.
And remember the alternative. Bender has said investors sometimes ask whether they should skip the TFSA and hold their foreign ETFs in a taxable account to recover the withholding tax. His answer was that it's usually better to use the TFSA and not worry about the drag, because the taxable route brings yearly tax on dividends and tax on capital gains when you sell.
Keep it in proportion The 15% withholding tax costs a TFSA investor roughly 0.17% a year at today's S&P 500 yield. A fund charging 1.5% a year costs about nine times as much. Fix fees first. Then worry about withholding tax. |
If you're paying high fees anywhere in your accounts, read The "Tiny" 1% Fee That Can Quietly Steal a Quarter of Your Retirement. It matters far more than this tax.
The 7 S&P 500 ETFs Canadians Actually Choose From
These are the seven Canadian-listed S&P 500 ETFs most investors compare. Here is how they stack up, using fund data as of November 6, 2026 (fees checked against the fund companies' own pages where available).
ETF | Provider | Yearly fee (MER) | How it owns the S&P 500 | CAD-hedged? | Size (CAD) | 10-year return |
VFV | Vanguard | 0.08% | Holds Vanguard's US-listed VOO | No | $35.7 billion | 15.57% |
ZSP | BMO | 0.09% | Holds the stocks directly | No | $24.9 billion | 15.55% |
XUS | iShares | 0.09% | Holds iShares' US-listed IVV | No | $13.3 billion | 15.55% |
HXS | Global X | 0.11% + 0.49% trading costs | Total return swap with a bank | No | $6.9 billion | 15.43% |
XSP | iShares | 0.09% | Holds IVV, hedged to CAD | Yes | $15.7 billion | 13.45% |
VSP | Vanguard | 0.08% | Holds VOO, hedged to CAD | Yes | $6.2 billion | 13.51% |
ZUE | BMO | 0.09% | S&P 500, hedged to CAD | Yes | $4.8 billion | 13.42% |
Look at the first three rows. Over ten years, VFV, ZSP and XUS returned within 0.02% a year of each other. These funds are, for practical purposes, the same product with different labels.
The big gap is between unhedged and hedged funds. We'll come back to that.
The Real "All-In" Cost Inside a TFSA
The fee printed on the fund is only part of what you pay in a TFSA. Add the withholding drag and you get the number that matters.

Here is the math behind the chart, assuming a 1.1% dividend yield:
VFV: 0.08% fee + about 0.165% withholding = about 0.25% a year
ZSP and XUS: 0.09% fee + about 0.165% withholding = about 0.26% a year
VOO: 0.03% fee + about 0.165% withholding = about 0.20% a year, before the cost of converting your Canadian dollars to US dollars
HXS: 0.11% fee + 0.49% trading costs, with no withholding = about 0.60% a year
On paper, VOO looks cheapest. In real life, for most TFSA investors, it isn't. And HXS, the fund built to avoid withholding tax, is the most expensive of the lot.
Those two traps are where the real damage happens.
Mistake No. 1: Paying 0.60% a Year to Dodge 0.17%
HXS, the Global X S&P 500 Index Corporate Class ETF, uses a clever structure. It doesn't own any S&P 500 stocks. Instead, it signs a "total return swap" with one or more banks, which agree to pay the fund whatever the S&P 500 returns, dividends included.
Because the fund never receives US dividends, no US withholding tax is taken. The dividends show up inside the unit price instead of being paid out.
That sounds perfect for a TFSA. The catch is the price of the swap.
In December 2024, Global X announced that the swap costs for HXS would rise from up to 0.30% a year to up to 0.50% a year, starting January 1, 2025, because of changing swap market conditions. Those costs don't appear in the 0.11% MER. They show up in the trading expense ratio, which was 0.49% as of June 30, 2026.
Now run the numbers on a full $109,000 TFSA:
VFV: about 0.25% all-in = about $270 a year
HXS: about 0.60% all-in = about $650 a year
You would be paying roughly $380 more each year to avoid about $180 of withholding tax.
There are other things to weigh, too. A swap depends on the bank counterparty keeping its promise. And swap costs are not fixed: the fund's own disclosure says they can rise or fall.
HXS's 10-year return (15.43% a year) was already a little behind VFV's (15.57%), and much of that decade came before the 2025 swap cost increase.
The lesson Never judge an investment by one cost alone. Add up everything you pay, every year. A fund that "avoids tax" can still leave you with less money. |
HXS can still have a place for some investors in taxable accounts, where it changes how and when you are taxed. Whether it suits you there depends on your tax bracket, so that is a conversation for a tax professional. Inside a TFSA, where there is no Canadian tax to defer, its main advantage disappears.
Mistake No. 2: Buying VOO in Your TFSA the Expensive Way
VOO is a superb fund. Vanguard charges just 0.03% a year for it. If you live outside North America, it may be one of the best ways to own the S&P 500, as I explain in VOO, CSPX or VT? The "One Fund for Life" Decision Made Simple.
But in a Canadian TFSA, VOO's advantage over VFV shrinks to just 0.05% a year, because both lose the same 15% withholding tax. On $109,000, that is about $55 a year.
Now look at what it costs to get there. VOO trades in US dollars. Many Canadian brokerages build a spread of roughly 1.5% to 2.5% into their exchange rate when you convert. Converting $109,000 at a 1.5% spread costs about $1,635.

At $55 a year in fee savings, it takes about 30 years just to earn back one conversion. And if you later convert back to Canadian dollars to spend the money, you may pay the spread again.
The cheaper way to convert: Norbert's Gambit
There is a well-known workaround named after Norbert Schlenker, the Canadian adviser credited with the idea. You buy a currency ETF such as DLR in Canadian dollars, ask your brokerage to "journal" it to its US-dollar twin, DLR.U, and then sell it for US dollars.
Done right, it costs a commission or a small flat fee instead of a percentage. Wealthsimple, for example, charges a flat $9.95 plus tax for the journaling route, compared with the percentage-based fee on its instant conversion.
It works, but it takes several steps and a few days. And at the end of it, your VOO in a TFSA still loses the same 15% as VFV. All that effort saves you 0.05% a year.
Two more VOO traps people forget
The W-8BEN form. If your brokerage doesn't have a valid W-8BEN on file, US dividends can be withheld at 30% instead of 15%. These forms expire at the end of the third calendar year after you sign them, so check yours.
US estate tax. US-listed ETFs such as VOO count as US property for US estate tax. The Canada-US treaty gives Canadians a prorated credit based on the US exemption, which is US$15 million in 2026, so most Canadian estates below that worldwide size end up owing nothing. But your executor may still have US paperwork to file to claim that relief. Canadian-listed funds like VFV, ZSP and XUS avoid this question entirely. I cover how this works in If You Live Outside America and Own VOO, Your Family Could Lose Up to 40% of It to the US Taxman.
Bottom line on VOO In an RRSP, a large US-listed holding like VOO can make sense, because the 15% disappears. In a TFSA, VOO saves you about 0.05% a year and adds currency costs, paperwork and estate questions. For most people, VFV, ZSP or XUS is the simpler and cheaper choice. |
Mistake No. 3: Letting the 15% Scare You Out of Investing at All
This is the costliest mistake of the three, and it is far more common than people think.
A TD survey conducted by Léger in October 2025 found that 65% of Canadians hold a TFSA, but 39% of them aren't investing the money inside it. Among Gen Z and Millennials, it was 41%.
Some people hear about withholding tax and decide US stocks "don't belong" in a TFSA at all. They leave the money in cash, or they never get started.
Here is what that hesitation costs. The chart below assumes you invest $7,000 a year for 25 years and earn 7% a year before costs. It is an illustration, not a forecast.

Look at the gap between the green and dark blue bars. VFV in a TFSA, after the 15% withholding tax and its fee, ends about $15,000 behind a world with no withholding tax at all, on $175,000 contributed.
Now look at the red bar. A fund charging 1.5% a year ends about $78,600 behind VFV. And money that sat in cash would be further behind still.
The withholding tax is a pebble in your shoe. High fees and not investing at all are the boulders.
If the fear underneath all this is really "what if the market crashes right after I invest?", read Has the S&P 500 Ever Lost Money Over 20 Years?. The long-term record is calming.
Hedged or Unhedged: Which Should You Pick?
When you buy VFV, ZSP or XUS, you own American companies priced in US dollars. So your return in Canadian dollars depends partly on the exchange rate.
If the US dollar rises against the Canadian dollar, your unhedged fund gets a boost. If it falls, your fund takes a hit. Hedged versions (VSP, XSP, ZUE) try to remove that currency effect.
Over the ten years to November 6, 2026, unhedged funds earned about 15.5% a year in Canadian dollars. The hedged versions earned about 13.5%. Over that stretch, currency moves and the cost of hedging both worked against the hedged funds.

That doesn't mean unhedged always wins. Currency moves can reverse for years at a time.
Here is a simple way to choose:
Choose unhedged (VFV, ZSP, XUS) if you can sit through currency swings and want the simplest, cheapest option.
Choose hedged (VSP, XSP, ZUE) if currency swings would tempt you to sell at a bad time, and you want your results to track the S&P 500 itself more closely.
Either way, the hedged funds still lose the same 15% withholding tax in a TFSA. And whatever you choose, stick with it. Switching after a big currency move is just another way of buying high and selling low.
VFV vs ZSP vs XUS: Which One Should You Buy?
This is the question people lose sleep over. It deserves much less worry.
VFV holds VOO. XUS holds IVV. Both are "fund of funds" that own a big US-listed S&P 500 ETF. ZSP owns the 500 stocks directly.
You might expect ZSP's direct structure to save on withholding tax. In a TFSA it barely matters. In PWL Capital's analysis, a Canadian fund holding US stocks directly faces almost the same US withholding tax as one holding a US-listed ETF. Either way, the 15% is taken once.
So the real differences are tiny:
Fee: VFV charges 0.08%. ZSP and XUS charge 0.09%. On $100,000, that is $10 a year.
Payouts: VFV and ZSP pay distributions every quarter. XUS pays twice a year.
Size: All three hold billions of dollars and trade easily.
My suggestion: pick the one your brokerage lets you buy with the lowest commission, or the one you already own, and stop comparing. If you want a single tiebreaker, VFV has the lowest fee today.
You also don't need all three. Owning VFV, ZSP and XUS together is like owning the same house three times. How Many Index Funds Should You Own? Probably Fewer Than You Think explains why one good fund is often enough for a core holding.
If you worry about what happens to your money if a giant like Vanguard ever got into trouble, read Is Your Money Safe in an Index Fund?
Which Account Should Hold Your S&P 500 Fund?
Many Canadians have more than one account. Where you put the S&P 500 changes which fund is best. Follow the chart below.

TFSA, FHSA or RESP
Use a low-cost, Canadian-listed fund. The 15% is lost either way, so there is no reason to take on currency conversion, a W-8BEN form or US estate questions.
RRSP or RRIF
This is the one account where a US-listed fund like VOO or IVV earns its keep. Held directly, its dividends escape the 15% entirely. Bender has suggested this tends to be most worthwhile for investors with larger RRSPs and more than about $100,000 in foreign stocks. Below that, the currency conversion and extra steps can outweigh the savings.
Non-registered (taxable) account
The US still withholds 15%, but you can usually claim it back as a foreign tax credit when you file. You will pay Canadian tax on the dividends and on gains when you sell, so this account comes after your TFSA and RRSP for most people.
Want a broader view on whether to own just the S&P 500 or the whole world? See VOO vs VT: Should You Own Just the S&P 500 or the Whole World?
What to Do Tonight: Your 10-Minute TFSA Checklist
Your 10-minute checklist
|
If you want a system that runs with almost no effort, Who Else Wants to Invest Just 15 Minutes a Year? shows you how. And if the market drops sharply after you start, keep The Market Just Dropped 20%. Here's What Calm Investors Do Next handy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best S&P 500 ETF for a TFSA?
For most Canadians, a low-cost, Canadian-listed, unhedged fund such as VFV (0.08% MER), ZSP (0.09%) or XUS (0.09%). All three track the S&P 500 almost identically. Inside a TFSA, they lose the same 15% of US dividends to withholding tax as US-listed VOO, without the currency conversion costs.
Is VFV or VOO better in a TFSA?
In a TFSA, both lose 15% of their US dividends to withholding tax, so VOO's only edge is a fee that is about 0.05% a year lower. That is often wiped out by currency conversion costs of 1.5% or more. For most TFSA investors, VFV is simpler and cheaper overall.
Do I pay US withholding tax on VFV in my TFSA?
Yes, indirectly. VFV holds the US-listed VOO, and 15% of VOO's dividends are withheld before they reach the Canadian fund. You won't see a separate line for it; the fund simply pays out less. At today's yields, the cost is about 0.17% a year.
Can I get the 15% withholding tax back in my TFSA?
No. In a taxable account you can usually claim the 15% as a foreign tax credit. But TFSA income isn't taxed in Canada, so there is nothing to claim the credit against, and the US doesn't recognize the TFSA as a retirement account under the tax treaty.
Is HXS a good choice for a TFSA?
HXS avoids US withholding tax by using a swap, but its total yearly cost, including trading expenses mostly from the swap, was about 0.60% as of mid-2026. That is more than double VFV's roughly 0.25% all-in cost, so it usually costs TFSA investors more than the tax it avoids.
Should I hold US stocks in my TFSA or my RRSP?
For withholding tax, US-listed ETFs held directly in an RRSP or RRIF avoid the 15% entirely. A TFSA does not. But both accounts shelter your growth, and the drag in a TFSA is small. If you have room in both, many investors hold US-listed funds in the RRSP and Canadian-listed funds in the TFSA.
Do I pay US tax on capital gains in my TFSA?
No. US withholding tax applies to dividends, not to capital gains. When your S&P 500 fund rises in value and you sell inside your TFSA, that gain is not taxed by the US or by Canada.
How much can I put in my TFSA in 2026?
The 2026 TFSA limit is $7,000. If you have been eligible since 2009 and have never contributed, your total room is $109,000. The CRA usually announces the next year's limit in late November or early December.
The Calm Way Forward
The 15% US withholding tax is real. It is also small, predictable and, in a TFSA, unavoidable without spending more than it costs.
So don't let it push you into a fancy structure, a currency conversion you don't need, or worst of all, a TFSA full of idle cash.
Pick one low-cost S&P 500 ETF. Fill your TFSA a little every month. Leave it alone when the headlines get loud. That simple plan beats nearly every clever workaround.
If you've lost money in the market before and you're nervous about starting again, you're not alone, and it probably wasn't your fault.
My free 38-page report, "Why You Lost Money in the Stock Market (And Why It Wasn't Your Fault)," explains why so many ordinary investors lose money, why it usually isn't their fault, and how to start building wealth again, calmly and simply. It's free, and you can read it tonight.
About the Author
Stephen Loke has been a student of the market for more than 15 years. He is also an agritourism entrepreneur whose farm has been featured in Bloomberg News and Asahi Shimbun.
This article is general education, not personal financial or tax advice. I'm not a licensed financial adviser. Fund fees, tax rules and limits change, so check the latest fund documents and speak with a qualified professional about your own situation.
Sources
S&P Dow Jones Indices, "TalkingPoints: Why Dividend and Capital Return Strategies Have Stood Out in 2026" (S&P 500 trailing dividend yield of 1.12% as of April 30, 2026): https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/education/article/talkingpoints-why-dividend-and-capital-return-strategies-have-stood-out-in-2026/
Canada Revenue Agency, TFSA dollar limits table (2026 limit $7,000): https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/registered-plans-administrators/pspa/mp-rrsp-dpsp-tfsa-limits-ympe.html
TD, "TFSA contribution room and withdrawal rules" (cumulative limit $109,000 for 2026): https://www.td.com/ca/en/personal-banking/personal-investing/learn/tfsa-contribution-room-withdrawal-rules
Questrade, "TFSA Contribution Limits and Rules for 2026" (1% per month over-contribution penalty): https://www.questrade.com/learning/tfsa-contribution-limits-rules-2026
TD Bank news release, "Risking No Returns? 4 in 10 Young Canadians Missing Out on TFSA Growth" (November 12, 2025; Léger survey of 1,500 adults): https://www.newswire.ca/news-releases/risking-no-returns-4-in-10-young-canadians-missing-out-on-tfsa-growth-td-survey-842324400.html
Vanguard Canada, Vanguard S&P 500 Index ETF (VFV) product page (MER 0.08%; invests primarily in the US-domiciled Vanguard S&P 500 ETF): https://www.vanguard.ca/en/advisor/products/products-group/etfs/VFV
BMO, ZSP ETF Facts, January 23, 2026 (MER 0.09%): https://fundfacts.bmo.com/EtfEnglish/BMO_S%26P_500_Index_ETF-EN-CAD_Units.pdf
BlackRock Canada, iShares Core S&P 500 Index ETF (XUS) (MER 0.09%, semi-annual distributions): https://www.blackrock.com/ca/investors/en/products/251422/ishares-sp-500-index-etf
Vanguard, Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO) (expense ratio 0.03%): https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/etfs/profile/VOO
Global X, "Global X Announces Increased Swap Costs for Certain Corporate Class Index ETFs" (December 6, 2024): https://www.globalx.ca/news/press-releases/global-x-announces-increased-swap-costs-for-certain-corporate-class-index-etfs
WOWA, "Best S&P 500 ETFs in Canada" (fund sizes, 10-year returns and HXS trading expense ratio, data as of November 6, 2026): https://wowa.ca/best-sp-500-etf-canada
Justin Bender and Dan Bortolotti, "Foreign withholding taxes: How to estimate the hidden tax drag on U.S. and international equity index funds and ETFs," Advisor.ca: https://www.advisor.ca/practice/your-business/foreign-withholding-taxes-how-to-estimate-the-hidden-tax-drag-on-u-s-and-international-equity-index-funds-and-etfs/
Canadian Couch Potato, "Foreign Withholding Taxes Revisited" (July 11, 2016): https://canadiancouchpotato.com/2016/07/11/foreign-withholding-taxes-revisited/
Investment Executive, "ETFs and foreign withholding taxes" (Justin Bender interview): https://www.investmentexecutive.com/news/industry/strategies/etfs-and-foreign-withholding-taxes/
Money.ca, "Norbert's Gambit: The smartest way to convert CDN to USD" (typical 1.5% to 2.5% brokerage currency spread): https://money.ca/investing/investing-basics/norberts-gambit
Wealthsimple Help Centre, "Convert currency with Norbert's Gambit" (flat $9.95 fee): https://help.wealthsimple.com/hc/en-ca/articles/45418222943131-Convert-currency-with-Norbert-s-Gambit
Wise, "What you need to know about form W-8BEN in Canada" (30% default vs 15% treaty rate; forms expire after the third calendar year): https://wise.com/ca/blog/form-w-8ben-canada
TD Wealth, "U.S. Estate Tax and High Net Worth Canadians" (US$15 million exemption for 2026; US-listed ETFs are US-situs assets): https://wealthoffice.td.com/?p=4733




Comments